WARNING: Some people may find the following comments offensive.
I am writing this in response to the comments I've seen concerning the death of Dale Earnhardt this past Saturday. I have seen his death characterized as a "tragic loss", as a "stunning blow", as a "terrible tragedy". It is none of these. Dale Earnhardt chose to participate in a dangerous sport, one which involves driving vehicles at extremely high speeds. A sport where the slightest miscalculation, the wrong assumption, someone else's error, equipment failure, track conditions, or other factors can cause a vehicle to crash, leading to driver injury or death. That is the nature of the sport; everyone who participates in this sport is aware of the danger.
I will repeat what I said this past summer in responding to the deaths of two young drivers on the NASCAR circuit: it is a shame when anyone dies before their time, it is painful to anyone who knew them personally, such as family and friends, but it is not a tragedy! The bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie was a tragedy. The recent earthquakes in India and El Salvador are a tragedy. The genocide that has taken place in Kosovo and Rwanda is a tragedy. The death of a man, no matter how popular, who chose to participate in a dangerous sport, is not. Many people try to climb Mount Everest: some of them die. Are their deaths tragedies? Some people do base-jumping (not sure if that's the right term - I mean parachuting) off of bridges and buildings: if something goes wrong, they die. Is that a tragedy?
I am not saying that it is wrong to mourn the death of Dale Earnhardt. For those of you who follow racing, for those of you who were fans of his, for those of you who respected his ability as a race car driver, his death affects you. His loss affects the sport, since he was a highly visible figure within it. But death is a possible end result of the sport, one that every driver faces when they get behind the wheel of a car on a racetrack. So don't label his death a tragedy.
------------------ Jim Mac '98 Silver SS #108
Posted by Happy_Dan (Member # 118) on :
I guess it is in your definition of a tragedy. Does a tragedy only occur when it is unexpected? There is risk, yes I agree. But we don't "expect" to see anyone get killed. We know it can happen. It is sad, still a shock even knowing it can happen, emotional, etc. I call that tragic. It hurts those of us who feel a connection. Let me put it in another way, there are many people that I call friends on these boards. Many drive agressively, on and off the track. Many are fathers, mothers brothers, sisters or friends. There is a risk that they could die in any noumber of ways. Some that they increased the risk (like driving at high speed. If they are lost to us, it is tragic. To me, losing Dale is much the same. So again, I understand your points completely and I cannot admit to "surprise" but it is al in how you define a word and the context you use it in.
Posted by poSSum (Member # 119) on :
JIm Mac, I understand what you are saying, but your thesis on "tragedy" breaks down to a "deaths per whatever unit" type of analysis. If an activity is deemed "high risk" death is not tragic, if it is "low risk" then premature death is tragic.
What's the basis? Activities a life insurance company will specifically excluded from a policy? Death is a possible end result of any activity. By my understanding, and Webster's, of "tragic" and "tragedy", Dale Earnhardt's untimely death clearly meets the standard.
To expand what I'm saying ... If the president is assassinated ... is that a tragedy (let's skip the political jokes on this one) .. or because it has happened to others, is it just the nature of the office?
[This message has been edited by poSSum (edited 21 February 2001).]
Posted by amy00ss (Member # 106) on :
Here is the definition of tragic according to Merriam Webster.
Main Entry: trag·ic Pronunciation: 'tra-jik Variant(s): also trag·i·cal /-ji-k&l/ Function: adjective Etymology: Middle English, from Latin tragicus, from Greek tragikos, irregular from tragOidia tragedy Date: 15th century 1 : of, marked by, or expressive of tragedy 2 a : dealing with or treated in tragedy b : appropriate to or typical of tragedy 3 a : regrettably serious or unpleasant : DEPLORABLE, LAMENTABLE b : marked by a sense of tragedy - trag·i·cal·ly /-ji-k(&-)lE/ adverb